The resolution professional handling Subhash Chandra’s personal insolvency case told the National Company Law Tribunal on Thursday that responses have been served on all stakeholders, including several nationalized banks, as the dispute over the Zee Group founder’s repayment plan continues.
The five-member special bench, led by president Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal and comprising judicial members Bachu Venkat Balaram Das and Mahendra Khandelwal Das along with technical members Atul Chaturvedi and Ravindra Chaturvedi, granted the Central Bureau of Investigation three weeks to file its reply. The matter will next be heard on 9 January.
After several stakeholders raised concerns, the bench asked representatives of the parties to prepare a common compilation of documents so that all sides could refer to the same set of papers during proceedings. A lawyer appearing in the matter pointed out that the case involves more than two sides. “There are not two sides, sir, there are three sides,” he said, referring to creditors who oppose the repayment plan, creditors who voted in favour of it, and the resolution professional. The bench clarified that the RP would include its documents in the same compilation.
The case concerns Chandra’s liability as a personal guarantor for loans taken by companies linked to the Essel Group and the Zee Group. Government officials have said about ₹2,574 crore of the claims relate to loans for which Chandra had provided personal guarantees. Chandra has maintained that he did not personally borrow the money and that his net worth of ₹31.79 crore formed the basis of his repayment proposal.
At the heart of the dispute is whether Chandra’s repayment plan is binding on creditors that opposed it. The plan proposed a payment of ₹6.5 crore, including ₹6.25 crore to creditors and ₹25 lakh towards insolvency process costs, and secured 80.81% support from creditors by value. Creditors that voted against the plan included LIC Housing Finance, IDBI Trusteeship Services, HDFC Bank, Axis Bank, Canara Bank, Union Bank of India (UK) and RBL Bank.
A separate dispute centres on the voting process. Creditors alleged that the RP had wrongly admitted the claims of five entities — Veena Investments, Direct Media Distribution Ventures, World Crest Advisors, Lemonade Capital Advisors and Corpcall Capital Advisors — which together accounted for 61.78% of the voting share and helped secure approval for Chandra’s repayment plan.
NCLT member Nilesh Sharma, who approved the plan on 25 August, held that it would be binding on dissenting creditors and found no evidence establishing the entities as related parties. Chandra’s office has said the companies belonged to his younger brother, Jawahar Goel, whose business interests were separated from Chandra’s during a family business separation in 2008-09.