The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed the Competition Commission of India’s appeal against Star India, now JioStar, and Sony Pictures Network in a case over alleged anti-competitive practices in television broadcasting, and sharply questioned the regulator for letting the matter languish for nearly six years.

A bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran asked the CCI’s counsel what it had done since filing the appeal in January 2020 to have the case listed for admission and notice. “Are you serious? What steps have you taken in the last six years to at least get it notified for the purpose of admission, issuance of notice?” the bench asked. The court dismissed the plea over the delay while keeping the legal questions in the case open.

Court records show the CCI moved the Supreme Court in January 2020 against an October 2019 Bombay High Court judgment. The appeal was listed four times in the years that followed. Adjournments came mainly from changes in the composition of the bench, a request by the regulator’s lawyer and subsequent changes in the names of the parties. The matter was last heard in April 2023 and never advanced to the stage of notice or admission before Friday’s dismissal, nearly six years after it was filed.

The dispute behind the appeal

The case dates to 2017, when Noida Software Technology Park Ltd, a television channel distributor, approached the CCI alleging that Star India and Sony Pictures Network were engaging in discriminatory pricing and distribution practices. In July 2018 the commission directed its director general to investigate, having formed a prima facie view that the broadcasters’ conduct raised competition concerns.

Star India and Sony challenged that decision in the Bombay High Court, which in October 2019 set aside the regulator’s order. The high court held that the CCI had failed to carry out the prima facie assessment required before directing an investigation into the alleged anti-competitive conduct. The CCI then appealed to the Supreme Court in 2020.

What the ruling leaves open

Friday’s order ends the CCI’s challenge to the 2019 Bombay High Court ruling, leaving that judgment in place. By keeping the questions of law open, however, the Supreme Court did not conclusively decide the broader legal issues arising from the dispute.

The matter carries weight because it raised questions over the CCI’s jurisdiction to examine alleged anti-competitive conduct in television broadcasting, a sector that is also subject to its own set of regulations. The high court’s 2019 judgment had questioned the basis on which the competition regulator ordered its investigation.

Star India became part of JioStar in November 2024, after Reliance and Disney combined their Indian media businesses. The CCI, JioStar and Sony did not respond to emailed queries before publication.

Author