A high-powered committee on administrative reforms in Odisha has recommended that the state enact a law making computerised counselling mandatory for all teacher transfers, arguing that discretionary postings have stripped remote and tribal schools of staff and hurt the education of Scheduled Tribe, Scheduled Caste and poor children.
The Committee on Governance and Administrative Reforms (CGAR), set up by the Odisha government to suggest reforms in the Scheduled Tribes and Scheduled Castes Development, Minorities and Backward Classes Welfare (SSD) department, submitted its report last month. The three-member panel is headed by former Odisha chief secretary Jugal Kishore Mohapatra. Its members are former Karnataka chief secretary TM Vijay Bhaskar and Om Prakash Agrawal, a former joint secretary in the Department of Personnel and Training.
The panel found that existing transfer guidelines and the computerised portal were not enough to prevent arbitrary decisions because the process lacked statutory backing. It said government orders and departmental rules can be changed, suspended or amended to accommodate exceptions, while an Act passed by the state legislature would provide a stronger legal safeguard. Under a law, it said, a violation would become illegal and any manual bypass could be challenged directly in the High Court.
The committee said teachers seeking postings at places of their choice often spend considerable time and money obtaining recommendation letters and pursuing transfer cases. This leads to movement from remote, rural and poorly connected areas to urban and better-connected locations. “This deprives the neediest schools of teachers and permanently affects the learning process of ST, SC and other poor children,” the committee said in its recommendations.
Staffing shortages in tribal districts
The recommendations follow persistent teacher shortages in tribal-dominated districts, where teachers often seek transfers to urban centres. In June this year, 648 teachers from Koraput, Malkangiri, Nabarangpur and Rayagada districts applied for transfers outside their districts under the terminal illness quota. The volume of applications forced district education officials to set up a medical board to verify whether the terminal illness claims were genuine.
Large-scale transfers from tribal areas to urban centres have produced a skewed student-teacher ratio. In Mayurbhanj, residential schools run by the SSD department have 46-50 students per teacher, against Right to Education Act norms of 30:1 and 35:1. Rayagada has 84 primary schools functioning with a single teacher, while Koraput has 119 such schools. The Unified District Information System for Education Plus report for 2025-26 showed Odisha had 1,458 single-teacher schools, up from 1,089 in the previous academic year.
Dibakar Sabar, president of the Rayagada district unit of the Odisha Adibasi Manch, called for the cancellation of informal deputations of teachers to urban schools. “The School and Mass Education department should order a blanket cancellation of all informal, administrative deputations to urban schools, mandating that personnel report back to their sanctioned rural stations,” he said. He also cited the 2011 Census, which put literacy among the tribal population at 52.24 per cent, well below Odisha’s overall literacy rate of 72.87 per cent.
Interim steps and wider reforms
Until a law is in place, the committee said the government should use software being developed by the Odisha Computer Application Centre (OCAC) for teachers’ transfers. At present, district-level transfer committees handle the process.
To address reluctance to serve in Sevashram and Ashram schools in remote tribal pockets, the panel recommended reserving a suitable percentage of vacancies in these institutions for candidates from local forest-dwelling tribal communities.
On departmental restructuring, the committee recommended separate administrative departments for Scheduled Tribes and Scheduled Castes, besides Other Backward Classes and minorities, with independent directorates and field-level offices. It noted that Scheduled Tribes account for 22.85 per cent and Scheduled Castes 17.12 per cent of Odisha’s population. A separate department for tribal development was particularly necessary, it said, because of relatively poor human development indicators and high poverty among the state’s tribal population. At present, the departments dealing with the welfare of Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes, OBCs and minorities operate under a common Commissioner-cum-Secretary and share the same field-level administrative structure, even though they are formally divided into two departments under the state’s Rules of Business.
The state government did not immediately comment on the recommendations.