The Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has held that capital gains arising from the transfer of shares of a US entity, which indirectly held an Indian company, are not taxable in India under the India-Ireland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA). The ruling, in the case of FireEye Ireland Limited v. ACIT, turns on the wording of Article 13 of the treaty and rejects the tax department’s attempt to read a domestic deeming provision into it.
RSM India, which issued a flash note on the decision, said the ruling reiterates that India’s taxing rights in a cross-border transaction must be determined having regard to the language of the applicable tax treaty.
What the case involved
The appellant is a company incorporated in Ireland and a tax resident of Ireland under the India-Ireland DTAA. It is part of the FireEye Group, which markets its offerings to customers across non-American regions, including India. In India, the group provided cybersecurity solutions comprising standard software along with incidental updates and support, consulting services, and the sale of accessories and appliances.
During FY22, as part of an internal restructuring, the appellant transferred its ownership interest in 17 group entities, including the US entity FireEye International LLC (FE LLC), to Mandiant Ireland. FE LLC in turn held the Indian company Mandiant Cybersecurity (MCPL), according to a Share Purchase Agreement dated 23 July 2021.
The appellant furnished a valid Tax Residency Certificate for the year under consideration and was eligible to claim benefits under the India-Ireland DTAA, having neither a physical presence nor a permanent establishment in India. It therefore reported the capital gain arising from the transfer of its ownership in FE LLC as not taxable in India, relying on Article 13(6) of the treaty, the residuary clause for gains not covered by the specific provisions. It also claimed the exemption available under domestic Irish law for intra-group transfers.
The department’s position
During assessment, the Assessing Officer characterised the transaction as an indirect transfer of shares of MCPL on the basis that FE LLC derived substantial value from assets located in India. The officer invoked Explanation 5 to Section 9(1)(i) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and Article 13(5) of the India-Ireland DTAA to hold that the capital gains arising from the transaction were taxable in India. The department further alleged that the transaction resulted in double non-taxation and constituted an abuse of treaty benefits, relying on Article 6 of the Multilateral Instrument.
The Dispute Resolution Panel upheld the Assessing Officer’s findings, and a final assessment order was subsequently passed determining taxable capital gains of around ₹497.73 crore.
What the tribunal decided
The ITAT held that the capital gains could not be taxed in India under Article 13(5) of the India-Ireland DTAA. That provision, the Tribunal observed, specifically addresses gains from the alienation of shares of a company resident in India. Since the entity whose shares were transferred was a US tax-resident entity and not an Indian-resident company, the gains fell within the residuary Article 13(6) of the treaty and were not taxable in India.
Principles set out in the ruling
Alienation is not the same as transfer under domestic law
The Tribunal rejected the Revenue’s contention that “alienation” under Article 13(5) should be equated with “transfer” as defined under Section 2(47) of the Act. It reiterated that a tax treaty is an agreement and not a taxing statute, and that its terms should ordinarily be interpreted in their context and in light of the treaty’s object and purpose. Domestic-law definitions may be referred to where the treaty terminology genuinely warrants such recourse, the Tribunal said.
Deeming provisions cannot be imported into a treaty
According to the Delhi ITAT, Explanation 5 to Section 9(1)(i) of the Act, being a domestic-law deeming provision, cannot be read into the India-Ireland DTAA in the absence of a corresponding provision in the treaty. Domestic-law deeming fictions cannot be imported to expand or enlarge the scope of taxation under a tax treaty, and the allocation of taxing rights must be determined solely in accordance with the express terms of the applicable DTAA. A unilateral amendment to domestic law, whether retrospective or prospective, cannot modify or independently expand the taxing rights conferred under the treaty, it held.
Treaty abuse must be demonstrated, not assumed
The Tribunal held that the benefit of the India-Ireland DTAA cannot be denied merely on the allegation of treaty abuse, in the absence of material demonstrating that the transaction was undertaken to obtain an undue treaty benefit. On the abuse charge, the Tribunal found that the possibility of double non-taxation, by itself, was insufficient to substantiate the Revenue’s allegation. Its conclusion took into account the appellant’s business operations and the wider scope of the group restructuring. The ruling highlights the relevance of the commercial background and supporting evidence when assessing treaty entitlement in a restructuring.
Taken together, the findings place the emphasis on the text of the treaty rather than on domestic deeming rules when a cross-border share transfer is assessed, and they require the tax authorities to point to specific material before denying treaty benefits on abuse grounds.