The Ghaziabad District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has ordered Delhi-based Concept Capital Infra Projects to refund ₹5.3 lakh paid by a Noida resident for a commercial shop that was never handed over, along with 6% annual interest and ₹10,000 compensation for mental agony and harassment.

The commission, in an ex parte order passed on October 23, directed the company to make the payment within 30 days. If it fails, the interest on the refund will rise to 9% per annum until actual payment. The order was passed by commission president Anil Kumar Pundir and members Shailja Sachan and RP Singh.

The complaint was filed by Sonu Singh, who booked a 114-square-foot commercial unit intended for a shop at The Core project in Sushant Aquapolis, Ghaziabad, in 2017. The unit was priced at ₹11,47,688. Singh paid ₹5.3 lakh towards the booking, including ₹4.3 lakh in cash, according to the complaint. He alleged that the company assured him and his father that it would develop the shop space and hand over possession within 36 months. The promised possession did not materialise.

Payment demands amid delay

Singh’s case was that the delay was followed by fresh demands for money rather than possession. The company issued a demand notice for ₹9 lakh on December 26, 2022, followed by another for ₹11.98 lakh on March 22, 2023, and a third for ₹12.2 lakh on October 13, 2023. The October notice warned that the booking would be cancelled and the amount already paid forfeited if payment was not made by October 14, 2023.

Before moving the consumer commission, Singh sent a legal notice through his lawyers on May 25, 2024. The notice was returned. The company’s response on June 6, 2024, was alleged to contain false statements about the transaction. Singh filed his complaint on June 24, 2024, seeking relief for the failure to deliver the booked property.

Ex parte proceedings

The commission issued notices to the respondents, but they did not appear or file a response. It began ex parte proceedings on September 27, 2024, and examined the documents and arguments presented by the complainant’s counsel. On October 23, it allowed the complaint.

The commission directed Concept Capital Infra Projects to refund the entire ₹5.3 lakh booking amount with 6% annual interest. It also ordered ₹10,000 as compensation for the mental agony and harassment suffered by the complainant. The order stated that the company should pay the compensation within 30 days; failing that, the complainant would be entitled to simple interest at 9% per annum instead of 6% on the principal amount until actual payment.

The ruling turns on the failure to deliver possession despite payment and the subsequent demands for more money. For home and commercial property buyers, the order underscores the importance of preserving payment receipts, allotment documents, possession assurances and notices. It also shows how a consumer commission can order a refund and compensation when a developer does not appear to contest the complaint.

Author