The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal’s Bangalore Bench has ruled in favour of Bengaluru businessman Amarlal in a dispute over assets seized in a 2018 search, holding that ₹4.1 crore in cash and jewellery worth ₹8.11 crore should be treated as business income rather than unexplained assets.

In its November 3, 2026, order, the tribunal set aside the Assessing Officer’s decision to apply Sections 69 and 69A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the special rate under Section 115BBE. The assets will instead be taxed at regular income tax rates. The tribunal allowed the department to treat the seized cash as business income.

Search and seizure

The case began on July 20, 2018, when Income Tax Department officials searched Amarlal’s residence and locker in Bengaluru. They seized ₹3.9 crore in cash from the locker and ₹20 lakh from the residence, for a total of ₹4.1 crore. The search also led to the seizure of jewellery valued at ₹8.11 crore, consisting of 751.52 grams of gold and diamonds weighing 81.470 carats. Two watches valued at ₹16.25 lakh were also taken from the locker.

After the search, the Assessing Officer invoked Section 69A to treat the cash as unexplained money and sought to tax it at the special rate under Section 115BBE. The officer also treated the jewellery and watches as unexplained investments under Section 69 and rejected the taxpayer’s explanations.

Taxpayer’s explanation

During assessment proceedings, Amarlal said he had filed an income tax return declaring total income of ₹19.26 crore, including ₹18.11 crore from business activities. He said the cash in the locker represented accumulated earnings from earlier years through real estate commission and money-lending work. The ₹20 lakh found at his residence, he said, belonged to different family members.

On the jewellery, Amarlal argued that its value had already been included in the business income declared for the relevant previous year. He also said the jewellery had been disclosed in wealth tax returns filed by him and his family members. The two watches, he submitted, were gifts from his sister and their value had been accounted for in his income tax return.

The Assessing Officer did not accept these explanations and classified the seized assets as unexplained.

Tribunal findings

Amarlal challenged the assessment before the ITAT Bangalore Bench with the help of a chartered accountant. The tribunal considered his statement recorded under Section 132(4) during the search, in which he explained the nature and source of the cash. It also examined his audited financial statements and income tax returns, which showed that business activities were his primary source of income.

The tribunal noted that wealth tax returns for Assessment Year 2015-16 showed the jewellery had been disclosed earlier. It also took into account an affidavit of withdrawal submitted before a notary on July 23, 2018, three days after the search.

The tribunal found that the Assessing Officer had not produced independent evidence to establish that the seized assets were unrelated to the taxpayer’s business activities. It therefore held that the cash and jewellery should be treated as business income, not as unexplained money or investments under Sections 69 and 69A.

Why Section 115BBE did not apply

The ruling matters because income classified as unexplained under Sections 69 and 69A can attract the special tax rate prescribed by Section 115BBE. By treating the seized cash and jewellery as business income, the tribunal brought them under regular income tax rates instead of the higher rate for unexplained income.

The order underscores the importance of maintaining audited accounts, filing accurate income tax returns and documenting the source of cash, jewellery and other valuable assets. It also shows that a taxpayer’s explanations and records can carry weight when the department has not produced independent evidence to contradict them. The watches had been part of the original assessment; the tribunal’s operative finding addressed the cash and jewellery.

Author